Costly Generosity1 John 3:16-18

In Deed and in Truth

This message is for the thing you gave up so that somebody else could have theirs, which nobody in that room knows about, and the small hard feeling that arrives every time it comes up in conversation

Nell did it in a phone call that lasted about four minutes and she has never told anybody, including her own husband, which she is aware is a lot to carry.

Her sister was going to have to pull out. That is the whole of the situation. There was a course, and a fee, and a date, and her sister at forty-one finally doing the thing she should have done at twenty-two, and a shortfall that appeared in the last fortnight because of something that was nobody's fault.

Nell had the money. She had it because it was the deposit on something she and her husband had been quietly working toward for a long time, which is now a year and a half further away and which he does not know is a year and a half further away, and she will tell him, and she has not yet.

She sent it. Four minutes. Her sister cried and Nell said stop it and they both laughed.

She would do it again. She would do it again tomorrow, and she is not conflicted about the act at all.

What she is conflicted about is what happens in her chest at family things.

Because it comes up. Of course it comes up. Her sister is doing brilliantly and everybody is proud of her and there is a photograph, and Nell's mother says isn't it wonderful, and Nell says yes, and it is wonderful, and it is entirely true that she is glad.

And there is a small hard thing that arrives at the same moment, every time, without permission, and it makes her want to leave the room.

She thinks it means she gave it wrong.

What got her was her niece, who is eleven and had been listening to the adults for too long the way children do. In the kitchen afterward, drying something, she said to Nell: Auntie Nell, do you think Mum could have done the course if you hadn't been there?

And Nell said something vague, and the girl, who is eleven and therefore relentless, said: because she couldn't have. I know she couldn't have. I was there.

I was there.

Nell stood in her mother's kitchen with a tea towel in her hands and could not say anything for a moment, and she could not have explained it to a single adult on the other side of that wall.

And the sentence that arrived, standing there, had nothing to do with the deposit.

She thought: it actually happened. Whatever my chest does at Christmas, the thing actually happened, and an eleven year old is the only person who has ever said so out loud.

Let me say the word properly first

Before we go on I want to be plain about what wealth means on this site, because the word is slippery and I would rather be clear than clever with a woman standing in a kitchen with a tea towel.

Wealth here means a portion. Not a balance, not a deposit, not the thing that is now a year and a half further away. A portion is the old table word for what is set down in front of somebody because they belong at that table, and Scripture takes that ordinary word and does something outrageous with it: God says of certain people that He Himself is their portion. That is the only sense the word carries here.

And now the paragraph that matters most in this article, said as plainly as I can say it. There is no ask on this page. Nothing here suggests you give anything to anybody, there is no link and no cause anywhere in it, and this site will never once tell you that giving produces a return, in any form, however gently it is worded. That wire does not exist here and it never will. You made a four minute phone call. That is between you and your sister and God, and this article has one interest in it: the small hard thing that arrives in your chest at family gatherings.

That is the whole job. Not to grade what you did, and certainly not to tell you that it will come back to you. To stand in the kitchen with you, and I would rather the word of God stood there, with the Holy Spirit doing the work, than that I guessed at what that feeling is.

You were included before you noticed anything. Scripture holds it, and the Holy Spirit is the one who lets it settle.

Deed and truth, which are not the same as feeling

John writes three verses about love that are famous for the middle one and worth reading for the last one.

By this we know love, that he laid down his life for us, and we ought to lay down our lives for the brothers. But if anyone has the world's goods and sees his brother in need, yet closes his heart against him, how does God's love abide in him? Little children, let us not love in word or talk but in deed and in truth.1 John 3:16-18

Read the last line very slowly, because it is the one that settles a woman with a tea towel in her hands.

Not in word or talk, but in deed and in truth.

He gives two categories, and he names the pair that counts, and feeling is in neither list. He does not say let us not love in word but in warm consistent emotion. He says in deed, which is a thing that either happened or did not, and in truth, which is a thing that either is or is not the case.

Both of those are settled about you. The deed happened in four minutes in a phone call and a woman is on a course. The truth is that she could not have gone otherwise, and an eleven year old just confirmed it in a kitchen.

You are not a woman who gave wrong. You are somebody who paid a real price and whose chest reacts at family gatherings the way a body reacts to a real price, and the written word does not scold anybody for that, and it is the Holy Spirit who makes the difference between agreeing that the deed counts and being able to stay in the room.

And here is what is true of you today, before you tell your husband and before anything about the eighteen months changes. You are provided for and your hands are open. His word says love is made real in deed and in truth, present tense, and His Spirit is the one who makes that a settled fact in a body rather than a verse a person nods at.

What the hard feeling actually is

Think about what got you at that sink. It wasn't the credit. You have gone to some trouble not to be credited.

It was: I was there, I know she couldn't have. It was the only person in that house who could state the fact stating it, out loud, without knowing what she was doing. You were starving to hear that it was real, and you still are, and the written word treats that hunger as reasonable rather than as wanting applause, and it is the Holy Spirit who says so to a person and not merely about them.

That is the honest thing under the hard feeling. It is not resentment of your sister. It is a body registering a genuine cost in a room where the cost is invisible, and a body does that whether or not the mind has settled the matter, and it will keep doing it at Christmas.

Here is what the word has already settled about you, so that His Spirit can settle it in you tonight. The deed stands. Jesus said one woman had done a beautiful thing while the room was still complaining about the expense, and He said it about a gift nobody else in that room valued, and He was in that kitchen while the tea towel was still in your hands.

The breakthrough

So here is the turn, and it is not that the feeling is sinful and it is not that you should tell everybody.

You are provided for right now, in that kitchen, with the deposit exactly as far away as it actually is and nothing here promising it will come back sooner. Scripture says love is in deed and in truth, and it puts feeling in neither of the two categories that count. His Spirit is the one who carries that off a page and into a woman at a sink.

Receiving it is not resolving the feeling first. It is agreeing that the deed stands while the feeling is still doing what it does. The small hard thing is welcome to arrive at Christmas. It gets no vote on what actually happened in four minutes.

Declare this over yourself

Say these out loud with one hand open and turned upward. You are in Christ and Christ is in you, and the authority in these words is His, delegated and never earned, carried by the Holy Spirit who was in that kitchen when your niece spoke. Jesus said in Matthew 17:20 that faith the size of a mustard seed is enough, and then named the part that settles it: speak to the mountain. So name the mountain honestly. It is not your sister and it is not the photograph. The mountain is the conclusion you reached about yourself the first time your chest went hard at a family table, that a woman who feels this must have given it wrong. Speak to that one, and however God answers and whatever He does with the years after this, the deed was done and it stands.

  1. Hard feeling that arrives when it comes up, you are not the truth about what I did, and you are answered here. Scripture says love is in deed and in truth, and feeling is not one of the two things named in that sentence.
  2. Conclusion that a woman who feels this must have given it wrong, in the name of Jesus get out of my mother's kitchen. Four minutes on a telephone put a woman on a course she could not otherwise have taken, and Christ is the One who calls that beautiful while a room is still discussing the expense.
  3. God, You are my portion, and Your word says we are to love not in word or talk but in deed and in truth. I thank You, because Your Spirit says it through an eleven year old with a tea towel, and my hand is open and turned over and I am not taking it back.

Why we ask you to say these out loud

The word this stands on

1 John 3:16-18

This message is free, and always will be. There is nothing to unlock, nothing to subscribe to, and nothing you owe for having received it.

More Manna

Matthew 25:40
Costly Generosity

It Already Arrived

Costly Generosity10 minNova
Matthew 25:40
2 Samuel 24:24
Costly Generosity

It Cost Me Something

Costly Generosity10 minImani
2 Samuel 24:24
1 Chronicles 29:14
Costly Generosity

Of Your Own Have We Given

Costly Generosity11 minEliana
1 Chronicles 29:14
Mark 12:41-44
Costly Generosity

She Went Home With Nothing

Costly Generosity11 minZariah
Mark 12:41-44
Hebrews 13:16
Costly Generosity

Such Sacrifices

Costly Generosity10 minCaleb
Hebrews 13:16
Leviticus 19:9-10
Costly Generosity

The Corners of the Field

Costly Generosity11 minZev
Leviticus 19:9-10
Matthew 6:31-32
Costly Generosity

The List I Made in the Dark

Costly Generosity11 minMelody
Matthew 6:31-32
Matthew 6:32
Costly Generosity

The Long Way Back From The Post Box

Costly Generosity10 minElias
Matthew 6:32
Genesis 18:1-5
Costly Generosity

The Three at the Door

Costly Generosity11 minAmir
Genesis 18:1-5
Exodus 36:5-7
Costly Generosity

They Brought Too Much

Costly Generosity11 minTahoma
Exodus 36:5-7
John 12:3-8
Costly Generosity

Why Was This Not Sold

Costly Generosity11 minSantiago
John 12:3-8
Psalm 63:1
Wealth Not Money

Flat Water, Six Years

Wealth Not Money10 minTahoma
Psalm 63:1
Luke 15:29-31
What God Owed

All These Years I Served You

What God Owed11 minTahoma
Luke 15:29-31
2 Corinthians 12:9
Enough For Today

Enough That Never Feels Like Enough

Enough For Today10 minZariah
2 Corinthians 12:9
Romans 8:38-39
Rich Toward God

Forty-Eight on an Ordinary Tuesday

Rich Toward God11 minTahoma
Romans 8:38-39
John 10:3-4
Money Not Enough

From an Aunt I Barely Knew

Money Not Enough10 minNova
John 10:3-4
1 Peter 2:9
Portion And Cup

Everything I Got Came Second

Portion And Cup10 minZariah
1 Peter 2:9
Psalm 42:1-2
Wealth Not Money

My Name on the Door

Wealth Not Money10 minImani
Psalm 42:1-2
Romans 11:35-36
What God Owed

Everything I Promised, Kept

What God Owed11 minSantiago
Romans 11:35-36
Lamentations 3:22-23
Enough For Today

In Case Enjoying It Uses It Up

Enough For Today10 minNova
Lamentations 3:22-23
Psalm 27:4
Rich Toward God

How Long It Took Me to Answer Her

Rich Toward God10 minZariah
Psalm 27:4
2 Corinthians 1:3-4
Money Not Enough

He Sends Money Every Month

Money Not Enough11 minEliana
2 Corinthians 1:3-4
Psalm 16:11
Portion And Cup

Everything Was a Stage On the Way

Portion And Cup10 minJubilee
Psalm 16:11
Jeremiah 2:13
Wealth Not Money

Nine Years of Rooms

Wealth Not Money11 minJubilee
Jeremiah 2:13
Malachi 3:16-17
What God Owed

The Book of Remembrance

What God Owed11 minZev
Malachi 3:16-17
Philippians 4:11-13
Enough For Today

Ten Past Four, and the Same Tightness

Enough For Today10 minCaleb
Philippians 4:11-13
Luke 12:20-21
Rich Toward God

Rich Toward God, and What It Means

Rich Toward God11 minCaleb
Luke 12:20-21
Psalm 68:5-6
Money Not Enough

The Flat Is Beautiful and I Eat Standing Up

Money Not Enough10 minJubilee
Psalm 68:5-6
Psalm 16:2
Portion And Cup

I Can Only Name What Is Missing

Portion And Cup10 minNova
Psalm 16:2
Deuteronomy 8:3
Wealth Not Money

Only Paper on the Porch

Wealth Not Money10 minEliana
Deuteronomy 8:3
Hosea 6:6
What God Owed

The Deal I Made in the Corridor

What God Owed11 minCaleb
Hosea 6:6
Exodus 16:18
Enough For Today

The Bread Is On The Table

Enough For Today9 minAmir
Exodus 16:18
Isaiah 33:6
Rich Toward God

The Inventory I Never Wrote

Rich Toward God11 minZev
Isaiah 33:6
Psalm 62:1-2
Money Not Enough

The Grant Came Through

Money Not Enough10 minTahoma
Psalm 62:1-2
Psalm 119:57
Portion And Cup

I Have Never Said It About Myself

Portion And Cup10 minCaleb
Psalm 119:57